> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theholdout.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Vimeo Could Not Kill the Cinema  Star
- URL: https://www.theholdout.com/vimeo-could-not-kill-the-cinema-star/
- Published: 2026-11-16T17:09:10.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T17:09:10.000Z
- Description: The Roundup #2: A sign-on letter to amend the federal film incentive bill to support micro-budget films, and our post-mortem financial analysis of Vimeo’s On Demand service and what it means for filmmakers and audiences
- Author: Abby Sun
- Tags: The Roundup, Federal Film Incentive, Vimeo, VOD, Indie Streaming, Dylan Skolnick, Fithian Group, Attend

*This week, in 🕰️ On the Clock, we chatted with the Chicago-based filmmaker Matthew Brdlik about his sign-on letter, making a case for micro-budget film support through a small business development lens. An 📣 Action Items piece from Sergio Andrés Lobo-Navia recaps how Vimeo will shut down Vimeo on Demand on November 20, what alternatives exist for filmmakers, and what it might portend for indie streaming services built on Vimeo Streaming (fka OTT). In 🚀 Everywhere Else, we quickly celebrate the reinstatement of Dylan Skolnick at the Cinema Arts Center, and explain how new platforms like the Fithian Group’s recently-announced Attend still come with practical challenges.* 

For everyone who doesn’t want to sell out...

[Subscribe ](#/portal/signup) 

---

## 🕰️ On the Clock: Lower the Threshold!

Matthew Brdlik, who recently finished a first feature on a high six figure–budget, had never organized anything like this before. But after seeing that the proposed Motion Picture, Television, and Entertainment Revitalization Act only supports films with a budget of at least $1 million, he wrote and circulated a sign-on letter asking Illinois’s congressional delegation to amend the federal film incentive bill to lower the threshold to $100,000.

More than 60 film workers signed—most are BTL, indie, or small businesses like equipment rental—making Brdlik’s letter a grassroots effort. The most consequential signatory is Eddie Linker, co-founder with Joe Swanberg of Forager Films, a longtime financier of low-budget fiction titles. 

The letter heartily endorses the federal film incentive, but also makes an argument that a lowered threshold would better support small businesses. Without the change, “our low end is getting uncompetitive, and the high end is getting subsidized,” Brdlik tells The Holdout.

[Read the full text and signatories of the letter hereLast updated Nov. 9, 2026Sign on Letter\_ Amend H.R. 10582 to Protect Illinois Small Businesses.pdf113 KBdownload-circle](https://www.theholdout.com/content/files/2026/11/Sign-on-Letter%5F-Amend-H.R.-10582-to-Protect-Illinois-Small-Businesses.pdf "Download")

**The letter’s main points:**

- Low-budget work keeps crews, rental houses, and vendors busy between studio shoots. Without that base, the bill’s rural and disaster-zone bonuses have no local infrastructure to draw on.
- Heads off the IRS objection by proposing third-party CPA audits for projects under $1 million, the way Illinois and New York already do for indie productions.
- Though micro-budget shoots aren’t a flight risk, the risk is that they never get made, making American micro-budget indies uncompetitive because many other governments cover entire budgets with grants.

In our chat, Brdlik also rebutted worries over incentives bleeding over to user-generated social content (“The bill already excludes social media, and Illinois can be used as an example, screening applicants through a multistep review”), and the lack of experienced CPAs who know film for independent audits (“Demand creates supply, and paying a little more gets you an auditor who’s on the ball”).

Producer Jeffrey Kusama-Hinte, of Antidote Films, was enthused by the letter’s appeal for a $100,000 threshold. If enacted, “essentially 100% of the benefit would end up in the pockets of working people—the money will circulate immediately back into the economy, further stimulating spending,” he says.

The clock is ticking for the bill’s lead sponsors, Senators Tim Scott (R-SC) and Adam Schiff (D-CA), and Representatives Nathanial Moran (R-TX) and Laura Freidman (D-CA). They have around a month to get the bill attached to a must-pass vehicle during the lame-duck session, which may limit the amount of possible amendments. If it isn’t enacted by January 3, the bill dies with this Congress and has to be re-introduced.

According to Brdlik, his Illinois representatives proposed the amendment, then “reached a stonewall” with the lead sponsors. The advice he got was to return with the support of more national organizations, and so, for now, he’s starting those conversations.

💡

This Thursday, November 19, at 2 p.m. ET/11 a.m. PT, Future Film Coalition is hosting a public webinar on the proposed federal film incentive and how indie film workers can get involved by contacting their representatives. Register [here](https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/sSp-zQaQQLekZC2THEfg6g?ref=theholdout.com#/registration). The usual disclosure: I am on FFC’s board.

Want to tell us something? 

Reach out to our tipline securely via ProtonMail (theholdout@proton.me) or Signal (theholdout.08)

[Support Us](#/portal/support)

---

## 📣 Action Items: What Vimeo’s Retreat Means for You

By [Sergio Andrés Lobo-Navia](https://www.theholdout.com/author/sergio/)

On November 20, Vimeo on Demand will be wiped. Founded several months before YouTube in 2004, Vimeo was a technical lynchpin for filmmakers, who used it to store works in progress and festival-consideration cuts of their films. Its Staff Pick laurels were arguably as important to a short film’s success as a major festival debut. Shorts filmmakers and shorts-focused platforms like Short of the Week are particularly reliant on embedded Vimeo links. 

Vimeo on Demand felt like a potentially revolutionary way to self-distribute and build an audience for your work. [Launched at SXSW](https://www.indiewire.com/news/general-news/vimeo-announces-vimeo-on-demand-a-self-distribution-platform-for-filmmakers-with-a-9010-revenue-split-40241/?ref=theholdout.com) in 2013, Vimeo on Demand was pitched as the future of indie releases. Later that year, Vimeo made further [headlines](https://variety.com/2013/digital/markets-festivals/vimeo-offers-toronto-film-festival-entrants-10000-for-first-run-digital-rights-1200596618/?ref=theholdout.com) by offering the 146 eligible world premieres at the Toronto International Film Festival a $10,000 advance for the first-run digital rights recoupable against a 90/10 split. [13 films took them up on their offer](https://filmmakermagazine.com/83602-vimeo-on-demand-announces-13-tiff-acquisitions/?ref=theholdout.com). At SXSW 2014, Vimeo [announced ](https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/sxsw-vimeo-pledges-10-million-686397?ref=theholdout.com)a $10 million fund offering similar advances to films premiering at the so-called “20 leading festivals of 2014” and to crowdfunded films. In 2015, TechCrunch wrote that Vimeo claimed [half a million viewers](https://techcrunch.com/2015/06/02/vimeo-svod/?ref=theholdout.com) purchased content.

Though transactions have been suspended since September, the closure of Vimeo’s On Demand video service has gone mostly unreported by the major Hollywood trades.

### **How Vimeo Got Here**

Warning signs started in 2022 after Vimeo was spun off from Barry Diller’s IAC. Long-time power users had their user plans changed and Vimeo asked for payments of [thousands of dollars](https://www.theverge.com/2022/3/15/22979126/vimeo-patreon-creators-price-increase?ref=theholdout.com) to continue using their accounts. After heated backlash, Vimeo introduced a flat 2TB monthly bandwidth limit and gave accounts that breached the limit a minimum of 30 days to respond to Vimeo before anything happened to hosted videos. As of October 2026, the 2TB limit on Core and Professional accounts applies to privately shared and embedded videos (non-embedded videos publicly shared on Vimeo have unlimited bandwidth limits). For filmmakers, the [optimistic rhetoric](https://vimeo.com/blog/post/new-free-plan?ref=theholdout.com) offered by the new leadership team is at odds with the core service that filmmakers have relied on Vimeo for: secure and embedded screeners. 

The current changes are in line with cost-cutting measures introduced by Vimeo’s current owners, the Italian conglomerate Bending Spoons. The Bending Spoons model is to realize “[25 per cent annualised returns on capital](https://www.ft.com/content/aebe2dbb-6d8b-4b3d-82c8-e64aebd4ef70?shareType=nongift&ref=theholdout.com)” through mass layoffs of current employees and replacing them with a [“700-strong army of so-called Spooners—their term for the enthusiastic and talented young people they hire to replace laid-off staff.](https://giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/c889730d-0ef3-4f11-8285-1ae724354742?ref=theholdout.com)” Bending Spoons went public in July 2026, and On Demand is exactly the kind of low-margin product this model sheds.

### **What It Means for Filmmakers**

According to Vimeo’s [On Demand closure FAQ](https://vimeo.com/ondemand/faq/sellers?ref=theholdout.com), filmmakers do not have to worry about file deletion. The file will remain in your Vimeo user account, but it will no longer be available for sale, nor will customers be able to access their purchases or rentals. But if your account gets downgraded, your films are at risk of deletion or having its embed links disabled. 

For indie filmmakers, streaming video distribution has dramatically changed since Vimeo’s halcyon days. Most of the films that were on Vimeo’s On Demand page are widely available elsewhere. Film aggregators such as Filmhub do the legwork of getting self-distributed films onto transactional platforms such as YouTube, Amazon Prime, and Apple TV, and bundles films into content deals for ad-supported VOD streamers such as Tubi and institutional SVOD Kanopy. 

Aggregators have their drawbacks. Entire subreddits are devoted to the hermeneutic study of aggregator terms and conditions (80-20 share with Filmhub after the platforms take their cut), stringent export requirements (one frame of black video at the head and tail of your export, caption duration minimums, integrated loudness should be -24 LUFS ±2 LU between -26 and -22 LUFS), and tech support for meeting those deliverables. Filmhub itself is also a subscription service offering four tiers of service. Its [free level of service](https://help.filmhub.com/plans?ref=theholdout.com) is “for clients who want to get their title into distribution with no upfront fees, without pursuing licenses with premium channels.” The $999/year Premium plan offers the ability for filmmakers to block certain channels. What differentiates a premium channel from a non-premium channel and why would you want to block certain channels? The Film Collaborative’s [Distributor Report Card](https://www.thefilmcollaborative.org/distripedia/distributorreportcard/filmhub?ref=theholdout.com) entry for Filmhub offers a disturbing example: films have been placed onto web browser AVOD YouTune, which makes them incredibly easy to pirate. The Premium level of support also offers online chat with acquisitions, but for the Premium Plus level of service, which costs $2000/year, you can have your very own dedicated acquisitions executive.

**Where to Go Instead**

**For TVOD Migration:** The sole media mention of the demise of Vimeo’s self-distribution platform was a paragraph at the end of an IndieWire [article](https://www.indiewire.com/news/general-news/fan-edits-legal-moonbeem-approved-clips-from-filmmakers-1235226818/?ref=theholdout.com) about Moonbeem, which is offering Vimeo users a [one-click](https://www.moonbeem.studio/vimeo?ref=theholdout.com) migration path to its new on-demand video platform. Moonbeem imports assets like posters, trailers, and subtitles, but not Vimeo on Demand’s sales analytics. According to founder Dan Sickles (co-director of *Dina*, 2017), migrating your storefront to Moonbeem "does not automatically opt anyone into fan edits,” though the option becomes available. 

**For screener uploads:** Frame.io may be the best alternative for filmmakers. Priced at $156/year for 2TB of storage, it offers a full set of password and file sharing controls. But Frame.io’s corporate owner, Adobe, is widely reviled by filmmakers for its monthly Creative Cloud subscription fees. Frame.io also lacks Vimeo’s distinct feeling of community that Staff Picks cultivated, and only its expensive Enterprise plan has per-viewer watermarking and DRM, which other services such as MediaSilo offer at lower price points. 

**On Vimeo’s upsell to Vimeo Streaming:** Vimeo is encouraging users to sign up for its OTT product (also known as Vimeo Streaming), which replaces On Demand’s individual rentals and sales with a monthly subscription-style service. Instead of selling individual films, Vimeo wants you to sell your whole library. Vimeo Streaming does offer TVOD and services similar to the old On Demand product, but is overkill for filmmakers trying to self-distribute a single title. 

**Backup best practices:** Decades of titles stashed on Vimeo are not a backup solution. It’s a useful tool to quickly share video with someone, but it is not designed for long-term storage. For long term storage, multiple cloud services and physical hard drives are the best solution for people looking to self archive their own work. 

Why multiple cloud services? As shown above, corporate restructures and rapidly changing business models can render the best services untenable. Redundancy is king, and if anything happens to one backup (credit card expires, your account is compromised, you accidentally delete everything) your data is still secure. Amazon Web Services (AWS)’s [S3 Glacier Deep Archive](https://aws.amazon.com/s3/storage-classes/glacier/?ref=theholdout.com) costs approximately $1/TB per month. AWS charges for data retrieval (often called egress) from their servers: restoring 10 TB of data would cost somewhere close to $900 just for data transfer. [Backblaze B2](https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-storage?ref=theholdout.com) charges about $7/TB per month. For egress, you’re allocated three times your average total storage per month, after which the charge is $10/TB. If you have 10TB worth of data, you’re permitted 30TB worth of downloads per month as a part of your service without additional charges. 

Physical backups should exist on multiple hard drives in different geographic locations. I recommend spinning HDDs versus non-spinning SSDs. SSDs store data as an electrical charge that slowly drains when the drive is unpowered. HDDs store data magnetically and can be kept in unpowered storage longer without risking data loss. Drive prices have increased dramatically throughout 2026 and long term storage is not a good reason to pay the premium for SSD drives. Best practices involve spinning the drive up yearly, performing an MHL hashcheck to check drive integrity, and replacing the drives every three to five years. I would put a readme document in the root of every drive with a manifest of everything located on the drive and what the folder structure is. Printing a copy of the readme and storing it with the drive is also important. If you aren’t around, it makes it easy for someone to understand that this is just not a box of dusty drives. 

LTO is the most secure way to store your data if you have access to an LTO deck. LTO tape is rated to last for decades. Though the starting price of a new tape deck starts at around $8,000, the tapes holding terabytes of data cost around $100\. 

### **The Future of Indie Streaming**

The On Demand shutdown also affects audiences, who lose access to their purchased films on November 20\. No refund is mentioned in Vimeo’s FAQ, and there’s no way to migrate a user’s purchase library unless the seller made a file download link available. This mirrors the results of a recent Short of the Week [audit of its selections](https://shortoftheweek.substack.com/p/can-you-ever-go-home-again) hosted on Vimeo, which found that roughly 150 titles had gone dark and were no longer available due to embed links that were disabled after Vimeo’s 2022 bandwidth restrictions. 

Every cinephile service built on Vimeo’s pipes is asking subscribers to trust that the catalog they pay for, and the watchlist they’ve built, will still be there next year—though its former leadership pivoted from serving indie filmmakers to [corporate](https://vimeo.com/enterprise/corporate-comms-toolkit?ref=theholdout.com) [internal](https://vimeo.com/solutions/communications?ref=theholdout.com) video solutions. Current Vimeo Streaming customers include Metrograph At Home and comedy SVOD channel Dropout, which [acquired](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/c3%5F2MQliYHc?ref=theholdout.com) former Vimeo On Demand stalwart Don Hertzfeldt’s work. While Hertzfeldt has left the Vimeo storefront, he is still very much in the building.

While Criterion Channel was the highest-profile indie streamer using Vimeo Streaming, it appears that the streaming site’s network traffic now points to another white-label streaming platform JWX. A Criterion representative was asked for confirmation, and this piece will be updated if they respond.

Bending Spoons’ other assets include filmmaker and filmworker favorites such as Airtable, FiLMiC Pro, WeTransfer, and Eventbrite. But brands are not your friend. We need alternatives for all of these products that treat filmmakers’ work as its primary focus. Creating in 2026 feels like pushing against a strong tide of compromise. There is an opportunity for an entrepreneur who wants to treat filmmakers as humans and not as content. The best service is the one that you can control on your own terms and not become dependent on. 

---

## 🚀 Everywhere Else

**🗞️ Dylan Skolnick Reinstated as Long Island’s Cinema Arts Center Co-Director**

- [This is not new news](https://www.facebook.com/CinemaArtsCentre/posts/pfbid02ztYkg4pLWrjQcQnVx2RFfuXpqK7YsHrf8Z8RA1oXsjNx23q3SoggvoCcPyPaST3Ll), but it’s worth celebrating all the same because the broader story shows that community outrage and—more to the point—donor and guest boycotts *can* lead to nonprofit board members changing their minds.
- Skolnick was not only a beloved programmer and film booker but the indefatigable former moderator of the Art House Convergence list-serv (sunset in spring 2024, RIP).
- Adam Vary previously [covered](https://www.indiewire.com/news/general-news/cinema-arts-centre-dylan-skolnick-firing-investigation-1235220785/?ref=theholdout.com) the past year at CAC and the allegations that led to Skolnick’s initial firing, and contextualized the common practice of cinema programmers supplementing their main posts with side, contract gigs booking films for other theaters.

**🗞️ Fithian Group’s Attend Theatrical Marketplace Launches With AI Marketing Recommendations and Direct Connection to Exhibitors**

- Attend [promises to connect](https://www.boxofficepro.com/attend-theatrical-marketplace-launches-at-afm/?ref=theholdout.com) independent filmmakers directly with exhibitors of all sizes, including chains, make matches using AI and demographics datasets, and streamline every part of the currently laborious independent booking process, including negotiating film terms and invoicing. Is it too good to be true?
- Attend’s alpha test film, before many of its current features were available, was Dan Levy Dagerman’s *You, Me & Her* (2023), which presumably helped Fithian Group work out some kinks. For Distribution Advocates, Dagerman and producer Selina Ringel [wrote up](https://distributionadvocates.substack.com/p/we-uncovered-just-how-many-pain-points) an extensive play-by-play of their marketing efforts and how they worked with Attend. I contributed to the editing of that case study, and though Ringel and Dagerman characterized working with Attend as “the top win,” they shared some practical challenges with attempting to partner with chain theaters. They also disclosed a $350K P&A spend, of which $100K went toward marketing funding, matching digital ad spends, and creating other marketing assets for theaters.

## Sign up for The Holdout

For everyone who doesn‘t want to sell out

Subscribe 

Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup. 

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.